This financial services brand’s ROI assessment empowered a whole new strategy

In our last blog, we explored why ROI analysis at Faraday isn’t just about proving value after the fact—it’s also about continually uncovering new opportunities.

We shared what that looks like at a high level. But this isn’t just a philosophy expressed in our marketing; it’s how we work every day. So today, we’re sharing a story from the ~real world~ that shows just how much insight you can unlock through our comprehensive ROI evaluation process.

It also drives home an important point: these evaluations can only achieve their full value if you actually engage with them. The top-line numbers might say “Yep, it’s going great,” but just because that’s good news doesn’t mean it reflects the whole story.

Sure, it’s going great, but how great, and where is there room for improvement? Which parts of the campaign are driving the most value? The least value? Do we need to revise any major assumptions to be more accurate?

Indeed when it comes to ROI analyses like these, digging deeper is where the real opportunity lies.

A deeper dive reveals something unexpected

Hi, ROI extraordinaire Chris Waite here. After I came on full-time at the start of the year as Faraday’s Head of Customer Analytics, I kicked off ROI initiatives with several of our existing customers. The goal was simple: move beyond one-time reports and start treating ROI as an ongoing conversation—one that actively drives value, not just records it.

With one financial services client, we began with my usual process: aligning on key assumptions—value per conversion, attribution logic, unit costs—and setting up monthly check-ins to track progress and dig into results over time.

And the returns looked great. Performance was strong, and the model was holding up. But during one of those check-ins a couple of months ago, someone on their team made an offhand remark that caught our attention: some of their hardest-to-convert prospects—sometimes rejected due to their low predicted conversion rates—actually had the potential to generate the most value if they did convert.

Our interest was piqued, so we ran the numbers.

We analyzed the relationship between Faraday’s prediction scores and the average conversion revenue. Sure enough, there was a clear pattern: while certain low-scoring groups converted less frequently, they delivered more value when they did.

The selection process didn’t need a full overhaul—but it did need a refinement. We brought the results back to the client, and together we incorporated these insights into their approach. By adding an additional variable into our selection process, we could proactively identify the majority of these high-value individuals and ensure their inclusion in the campaign. Once updated, the campaign began to improve—conversion rates dipped slightly (by design), but total revenue went up.

This is a perfect example of how our ROI reporting process uncovers new and unexpected insights that drive value. In this case, we used it to fine-tune suppression logic and reframe scoring thresholds—without a full process overhaul. The outcome was a smarter, more mission-aligned strategy that helped the client prioritize not just likely conversions, but the ones with the greatest potential overall value.

And through that process, we uncovered something more. These high-impact conversions weren’t just good for business—they were cultural wins. Inside the company, signing one of these clients—often individuals carrying significant debt—was seen as a major moment. It represented the core of their mission: to support people who need it most. The whole team felt it.

So yes, ROI is about financial returns. But sometimes, it's also about morale, alignment, and purpose. In this case, their investment in Faraday didn’t just lead to better outcomes on paper—it reinforced the values that drive their business forward.

From revenue recap to campaign shift

This paradigm shift is exactly Faraday’s goal when we present our clients with our ROI reports. We can talk about them driving value as much as we want but they drive the most value with buy-in and funding from the teams that use them.

In this case, thanks to the deeper ROI dive, the client was able to:

• Identify underutilized customer types
• Refine their lead suppression strategy
• Shift budget allocations across customer segments
• Drive more high-impact conversions

None of that was the original intent. But that’s the point—when ROI becomes an ongoing process, not just a retroactive check-in, it drives value in real time.

Why Faraday treats ROI like strategy

We’re not sharing this story to pat ourselves on the back—we’re sharing it because it highlights something bigger: most companies treat ROI as a postmortem. We treat it as a feedback loop.

At Faraday, ROI modeling isn’t a final deliverable—it’s built into every engagement from day one. We co-develop success metrics with our clients, revisit assumptions as new information emerges, and treat every report as a living document meant to drive change in real time. Because when ROI is treated as a collaborative, evolving process—not a static snapshot—it doesn’t just validate past performance. It unlocks new value, sharpens ongoing strategy, and turns every insight into an opportunity for future impact.

Coming up next

In our next post, we’ll pull back the curtain on how we build some of our ROI models at Faraday—what goes into them, what we measure (and why), and how we handle the gray areas most companies avoid.

Because the better you understand your own ROI, the greater your ability to power new growth.